By Bonnie Dorrick Kent
The inspiration of advantage ethics replaced dramatically throughout the overdue 13th century. although Thomas Aquinas, ultimate relatively in line with Aristotle's teachings, posits virtues within the emotional a part of the soul, simply thirty years later Duns Scotus argues that each one ethical virtues needs to belong to the need. The authorised, "textbook" account of ethics in this interval, first popularized via Etienne Gilson and lately revived through Alasdair MacIntyre, provides Scotus as a proto-modern philosopher who separated philosophy from theology and undermined the Thomistic synthesis of Aristotelianism and Augustinianism. This learn goals to supply a extra balanced account of the way Christian thinkers, together with Aquinas, reworked Aristotle's psychology and ethics.
Bonnie Kent strains past due thirteenth-century debates in regards to the freedom of the need, ethical weak point, and different concerns that helped switch the process Western ethics. She argues that one can't comprehend the controversies of the interval or see Duns Scotus in point of view with out paying due recognition to his rapid predecessors: the influential secular grasp Henry of Ghent, Walter of Bruges, William de l. a. Mare, Peter Olivi, and different Franciscans. likely radical doctrines in Scotus usually change into reasonable compared to different near-contemporary perspectives, and extraordinary Scotistic suggestions usually develop into whatever imminent commonplaces of Franciscan idea.
This research offers the controversies of the interval much less as a response through theologians opposed to philosophy than as real philosophical debates approximately difficulties raised by means of Aristotle's suggestion. And it offers Scotus's teachings much less as a holiday with culture than as a pretty typical reaction to concerns debated via his predecessors. the final target is to recuperate a part of a overdue thirteenth-century discussion in regards to the will and morality.
By explaining in a transparent, available kind the occasionally complicated concerns debated in this interval, Virtues of the desire is helping readers comprehend not just the ancient and doctrinal context but in addition the extra enduring philosophical difficulties posed by way of Aristotle's teachings
Bonnie Kent is assistant professor of philosophy at Columbia college. Virtues of the desire types a part of her carrying on with inquiry into scholastic modifications of old ethics. She is now writing a comparable ebook and enhancing an anthology of decisions on human nature from Aquinas's Summa theologiae.
Read or Download Virtues of the will : the transformation of ethics in the late thirteenth century PDF
Similar ethics & morality books
Ebook by means of Browne, Harry
Ethical issues is a concise and available examine such moral concerns as euthanasia, animal rights, abortion, and pornography. It offers a targeted set of perspectives from the unified viewpoint of 1 of North America's prime libertarian thinkers, and goals to impress notion and dialogue in addition to to counterpoint figuring out.
This well timed reader in ethical philosophy addresses an issue that strongly affected fresh eu reflections at the relevance of ethics for theories of democratic associations and democratic legitimacy. the talk facilities round the thought of a communicative ethics as articulated by way of J? rgen Habermas and Karl-Otto Apel, and it really is consultant either one of fresh makes an attempt to bridge the distance among Continental and Anglo-American philosophy and of the flip to language that has characterised a lot of modern philosophy.
Ebook by means of Tracey, Michael, Morrison, David
- Moral Responsibility: The Ways of Scepticism (Routledge Studies in Ethics and Moral Theory)
- On ethics and history : essays and letters of Zhang Xuecheng
- Morality within the Limits of Reason
- The Moral Demands of Affluence
- Being Good: A Short Introduction to Ethics
- The Rights of Nature: A History of Environmental Ethics
Extra info for Virtues of the will : the transformation of ethics in the late thirteenth century
He was lecturing, or preaching, as minister general of the Franciscans, and the Collationes in Hexaemeron were informal evening talks he gave to theology students and faculty at the Franciscan convent at Paris. Thus it is inappropriate to compare the Hexaemeron with a theology textbook, such as Aquinas's Summa theologiae, or even with a disputation or Sentences commentary, without acknowledging the differences in genre, just as it is inappropriate to compare an op-ed piece by one philosopher with a book or journal article by another.
S account of them. 43 The sections where the two editions agree would suggest that! 38. , 319-28. , colI. 6, n. , 92. 40. , colI. 6, n. 5: '"'Hi ergo ceciderunt in enores nec fuerunt divisi a tenebris; et isti sunt pessimi enores. Nec adhuc clausi sunt clave putei abyssalis. Hae sunt tenebrae Aegypti; licet enim magna lux videretur in eis ex praecedentibus scientiis, tamen omnis exstinguitur per errores praedictos. , V, 361). , Visio I, call. 3, n. 5: "Cautius ergo est dicere quod Aristoteles non senserit mundum aetemum, sive senserit sive non, quia tantus fuit quod omnes ipsum sequerentur et assererentur idem dicere; sic omnis lux detcnninata in praeccdentibus extingueretur.
Les questions disputees et les questions quodlibetique dans les facultes de theologie, de droit et demedecine (Turnhout, 1985), 50-P, r36. p. Bettoni, "The Originality of the Scotistic Synthesis," in John Duns Scotus, I26S-I96S, ed. J. Ryan and B. , r965), 31. Bettoni does not indicate from which work the remark is taken. Gilson (History 0/ Christian philosophy, 340) reports that the remark comes from Waiter's disputed questions but does not indicate which question. ARISTOTLE AMONG THE CHRISTIANS ...
Virtues of the will : the transformation of ethics in the late thirteenth century by Bonnie Dorrick Kent